What's Tops in Kitchen Counter Tops? Stainless Steel vs Stone

No matter how much work you put into cabinetry, flooring, or appliances, your kitchen remodeling project is probably going to be defined by your choice of kitchen counter tops. It only makes sense. The counters are the axis around which all your cooking, cleaning, and other kitchen activities revolve. And if you're spending the money to remodel your kitchen in the first place, it seems wise to invest in counter materials that will sustain their appearance over time and add a dash of extra elegance and value to your house. Two counter types that meet this description are stainless steel and stone.

Stainless Steel Counters Tops

If you've ever been in the kitchen of a classy restaurant (or seen one on TV), you know that stainless steel is almost always the kitchen countertop of choice for professional cooks and restaurant owners. It's not just because stainless steel countertops look sleek and modern, either. As the name indicates, stainless steel is extremely durable, resistant to stains, and easy to clean (it's the only kitchen countertop that can be regularly cleaned with bleach). Despite its reputation, though, stainless steel is not indestructible, and scratches and wear can add up over time. Also, not everyone is a fan of the chic metallic appearance of stainless steel, particularly those interested in conveying a warmer, more homely atmosphere in the kitchen. Stainless steel costs usually range from $75-$150 per sq. foot, depending on the contractor.

Stone Counter Tops

As mother nature's been proving for millions of years, stone is tough! Stone counters come in numerous forms, including granite, slate, limestone, soapstone, and the grandaddy of classy countertops, marble. These differing stone types are often combined in many countertop designs, and because of the unique look of all natural stone, you'll always be sure your kitchen has a distinct look and character all its own. While extremely durable (we are talking about rocks here), stone kitchen counters do require a lot of upkeep. Some stone counters may need stain resistant sealers to be reapplied every few years, and scratches and cracking are relatively common over the years, sometimes requiring expensive repair work. In terms of costs, stone countertops are usually more affordable than steel, ranging from $40-$100 per sq. foot, with high-end marble setting you back more. Still, the look, feel, and permanence of a well designed stone counter are hard to beat.

And the winner is. . .

For me, nothing tops a beautiful granite kitchen counter. It's relatively affordable, has a very natural but sophisticated look, and will last you for the life of your home.